Re: HTML != XML

Toby Speight (tms@ansa.co.uk)
10 Sep 1998 11:15:53 +0100


David> David Megginson <URL:mailto:david@megginson.com>

0> In article <199809091828.OAA02266@unready.megginson.com>, David
0> wrote:

David> The problem is that the HTML 4.0 DTD defines the <SCRIPT>
David> element as follows:
David>
David> <!ELEMENT SCRIPT - - CDATA>
David>
David> This is perfectly legal SGML, and HTML 4.0 is based on SGML. It
David> would actually be *wrong* to use &lt; and &amp; in a <SCRIPT>
David> element in HTML -- the browsers, probably by accident, have it
David> right (at least this far).

I think it should be pointed out that HTML was *changed* in order to
accommodate the browsers' behaviour. Earlier drafts (HTML 3.0, IIRC)
had <!ELEMENT SCRIPT - - (#PCDATA)>, but the browsers didn't deal
with it correctly.

--